Welcome New User! ( Create Account | Sign In )

Our members earned over $8,000.00 last month! Join Us

Start earning today!

 

This Question has not been awarded yet.

Post your answer now!

Question

Submitted 643 days ago...

anxiety

anxiety

New User (1)

Can our contractor put a mechanics lien on our home?

My "uncle" built an addition at our existing father in laws house. He NEVER made a contract or any change orders. Right after it passed inspection, he gave us a "bill" for $35,000 dollars. He said it was for the downstairs, which supposedly was Never included in the remodel. He Now wants, $45,000. Above what we already paid him. We had agreed on a price on a "contract" that my husband wrote up. My husband, up until the last week before he quit working, kept asking him how we were doing on the job, and he always said, " oh were on budget." Do we have any legal rights, not that we want him to come over and finish the job, but we have paid over $10,000 after he left trying to finish the job. Does he have any legal rights to that EXTRA money?

Share | Abuse |
 
Answers
Answer 1 / 5 - Submitted 643 days ago...

kbky11

kbky11

Brain (15,809)

This is really for the courts to decide, but if i wrote a contract for 45,000 and he wanted 10,000 more , ill be danged if i paid him another penny, and he could just sue , me , because id be in the right, he shouldnt have signed, this if he didnt honor it, your uncle is wrong,

Share | Link | Abuse
 
 
Answer 2 / 5 - Submitted 643 days ago...

Plane321

Plane321

New User (6)

Your uncle probably does NOT have any rights to the extra money. Why not call your state's commercial license department that governs licensing of contractors and find out? In Michigan, if the contractor has no license, you do not have to pay him one dime. Too late this time, but in the future, ALWAYS get a detailed quotation of exactly what work if being done with what kind of materials and the cost, including labor. Also, you should always ask for a start and completion date along with a payment schedule stating when you agree to pay as certain items are completed. Any changes should be confirmed in writing with the date and same detail with cost to you and when and how the extras are to be paid. If I were you, I would make that phone call to the state. As soon as you have more facts, sit down with your uncle and talk, talk, talk until you and he understand what happened. There are always two sides to every story and maybe he can prove he went beyond the original "contract" and you did get an extra value that you should pay for. Good luck.

Share | Link | Abuse
 
 
Answer 3 / 5 - Submitted 624 days ago...

TopOut783

TopOut783

New User (8)

Whether or not your "uncle" has a legal right to more money depends a lot on how well your husband wrote up the "contract" you assumed covered all the costs. Get all your documents together and keep them all. Write to your "uncle," even if you see him every day , by registered letter and ask him to explain why he is asking for funds in excess of the agreed upon amount. Ask for a detailed accounting of all expenditures made and payments received. Do nothing until you hear from him again; then take the entire matter to an attorney simply for a consultation to know where you stand. If the attorney says you don't owe, sit back and wait for "uncle' to sue you before actually engagint the attorney.

Share | Link | Abuse
 
 
Answer 4 / 5 - Submitted 624 days ago...

TopOut783

TopOut783

New User (8)

Whether or not your "uncle" has a legal right to more money depends a lot on how well your husband wrote up the "contract" you assumed covered all the costs. Get all your documents together and keep them all. Write to your "uncle," even if you see him every day , by registered letter and ask him to explain why he is asking for funds in excess of the agreed upon amount. Ask for a detailed accounting of all expenditures made and payments received. Do nothing until you hear from him again; then take the entire matter to an attorney simply for a consultation to know where you stand. If the attorney says you don't owe, sit back and wait for "uncle' to sue you before actually engaging the attorney.

Share | Link | Abuse
 
 
Answer 5 / 5 - Submitted 622 days ago...

jim5456

jim5456

Brain (2,933)

Yes he can put a mechanics lein and you have to get a lawer to sue and get it removed

Share | Link | Abuse
 
 
 
 

Answer This Question Now

Can our contractor put a mechanics lien on our home?

If your Answer is chosen as the “accepted” answer, you will earn ongoing royalties on this thread.
Simply type your Answer in the box below and post your answer.


Email Subscriptions

Author adds clarification

All new responses

Related Questions