My first impression is no, because sound waves need matter to vibrate in order to make any noise, but I can ask my Dad to make sure. He's as old as the universe itself. I'll have to ask him three times, though, because HIS HEARING"S NOT SO GOOD!
Submitted 145 days ago...
My first impression is no, because sound waves need matter to vibrate in order to make any noise, but I can ask my Dad to make sure. He's as old as the universe itself. I'll have to ask him three times, though, because HIS HEARING"S NOT SO GOOD!
Awarded Answer (What’s This?)
Answer 2 / 7 - Submitted 145 days ago...
In space, no one can hear you scream, meaning sound does not exist in a vacuum.
I've seen interpretations of cosmology suggesting that the shock wave from the Big Bang is still reverberating throughout the universe as background noise in minute distortions of wave forms. It's almost the stuff dreams, considering how heady cosmology can get, and it has almost no relation to life as we experience it.
Your question also has an embedded anthropocentric bias with the assumption that someone (or something, perhaps god-like?) could somehow exist above, beyond, or outside the action and thus be in a position to observe and experience the loudness. However, if the Big Bang represents the totality of reality at that instant, which expanded at some incredibly rapid speed within the first microseconds to form the universe, only much later coalescing into galaxies, stars, planets, moons, and ultimately sentient life, then clearly nothing existed at the outset able to form the experience of loudness.
This answer was edited by Brvtvs 83 days ago.
Reason: typo
As the others said, it probably wasn't loud. Sound needs a medium to vibrate in, and the vast vacuum of space isn't it. Also, the big bang created things like the laws of physics and sound (weird, but true!) within the first microseconds of the bang. So sound (or at least the physics of travelling sound) wouldn't even have existed yet.
I'll leave you with a philosophy question:
If no one was around to hear the big bang, did it make a sound? :p Maybe! But I wasn't around to hear it yet, and nobody was.
There is still a debate over who was the most popular of the big bangs, but many had their own favorites, like Glen Miller and Count Basie. During the big bang era of the late 30's and the 1940's, people would flock to halls all over the country to dance to the loud sounds they made. You can still get the recordings, and - if you turn the volume way up - they're still very loud. Hope that helps! ;~)
You would have to ask God or Goddess in their various incarnations, whichever of them happened to be around at the time to create it. Perhaps Shiva clapped his hands, or Shakti got angry at him and stamped her foot.
A sun exploding would not make a sound. So I do not think the big bang would be loud. Besides needing air to transmit the sound waves you would also need ears to hear the sound or it is just a vibration.
It was sooooo loud, it broke all the sound barriers and deafened all within hearing distance. And it was sooooooo bright, that it blinded all within seeing distance. And the shockwaves were sooooo powerful, it pushed all the galaxies across the known universe. That is why there is no one left around here to tell us how loud, how bright and how powerful it really was. All our neighbors were blown into the next galaxy and they can't hear, see or communicate with our poor, little lonely planet anymore.
This Question was awarded 79 days ago therefore you can no longer post an Answer. However you may post a comment below.
Thanks for all the great answers, though I have to admit, the vacuum topic and the "embedded bias" point mentioned did cause me to get another cup of coffee and reconsider the Big Bang might have been a silent, but deadly "universal whiff".
This answer was edited by slimjim270 79 days ago.
Reason: spelling
Add A Comment