Welcome New User! ( Create Account | Sign In )

Our members earned over $6,000.00 last month! Join Us

Start earning today!

 
Congratulations!
zoesmommy

zoesmommy

New User (6)

zoesmommy answer was awarded and will earn ongoing royalties from this thread.

How This Works?

 
Question

Submitted 41 days ago...

aashannon

aashannon

Beginner (17)

My brother is being a jerk..

My brother left my sister in law of 9 years to be with a way younger girl. He hurt his wife so bad and since thier breakup 2 months ago, I am the one that has been helping her through it. Well last week my brothers new girlfriend dumped him and now he's begging his wife back. She is asking me what to do but I believe he is feeding her bologna and isn't going to change. So my question is how do i help without making my brother hate me but telling his wife what my true feelings are?

Share | Abuse |
 
Answers
Answer 1 / 5 - Submitted 41 days ago...

bobintexas

bobintexas

Professor (1,341)

It's called conversation. Talk to her and if little brother finds out, tell him what a fool he's been and the past will always haunt him. Remember he's the one who left for greener pastures but landed in the weeds, not his wife and certainly not you. Didn't you ever slug your brother when you were little or if you did maybe it wasn't often enough. He screwed up and needs to live with it and any chastizing you do.

Share | Link | Abuse
 
 
Answer 2 / 5 - Submitted 40 days ago...

LissaC

LissaC

Brain (6,054)

I agree with bobintexas.
Your brother screwed up and now needs to know that it was not ok. If your sis-in-law welcomes himback with open arms, she is only letting his male ego know that what he did was ok and acceptable. And it is NOT! She needs to stand her ground, and it's hard to do because I am sure that she loves him but she needs to be big about it and show him that she will NOT tolerate that kind of behavior, otherwise he is just going to keep playing games with her and things will never get better.
As for him being against you for being on her side, you have every reason to take her side, she did nothing wrong, he did and you should not back him up in his ignorance. If he cant accept you taking her side, tell him to stop being an idiot to his wife and start doing what is right, then he will have you on his team!
Hope everything works out!
Let us know if you need anything!
-Lissa

Share | Link | Abuse
 
 
Answer 3 / 5 - Submitted 40 days ago...

aashannon

aashannon

Beginner (17)

I know it doesn't matter but he is actually 3 years my elder.

Share | Link | Abuse
 
 

Awarded Answer (What’s This?)

Answer 4 / 5 - Submitted 40 days ago...

zoesmommy

zoesmommy

New User (6)

Just be on both sides. He is your brother threw thick and thin but it sounds as if you are very close to your sister in law as well. Through personal experience it is hard to tell one or the other your personal opinion because you don't want to be drawn into it. If she takes your brother back just let her know don't let him in easy. Make him work for it and let him know what his actions are not ok. As for your brother being mad at you for it he should know that you do not condone his actions and that he shouldn't expect you to not be mad at him as well. Let him know as well as her that you are there for both of them and will be no matter the out come. Good luck to you!

 
Answer 5 / 5 - Submitted 40 days ago...

Laotian842

Laotian842

Expert (729)

Wow. This is a huge leap of faith on your part, going outside for advice, but here goes: As you know from observing others, you inherit family members, you don't have the luxury of choosing them, unfortunately. So naturally, you're going to be torn. And well you should be, because you've been pulled into the middle of this mess. You know your brother behaved like a complete jerk, but he's family. So you have to ask yourself a few questions: How important is this whole family thing to you? Does he need to be taught a lesson? Will he learn from it? And, will the two of you eventually reconcile, or is that important to you at all? However, if you feel strongly that your brother isn't going to change, you should (separately) tell that to both of them . . . and then, step back. They're both adults, they've been together almost a decade, they need to be the ones to make that fateful decision. But your brother needs to know -- from you -- of the predicament he has put you in, and that, even though he's family, because of the awkward position you've been thrust into, you are entitled (almost obligated, at this point) to give your opinion, given your involuntary involvement. Will it hurt him? Probably. But if you articulate how you feel cornered by this, he will understand. And as a result, he will probably get over it, eventually.

Share | Link | Abuse
 
 

This Question was awarded 38 days ago therefore you can no longer post an Answer. However you may post a comment below.

 
 
 
 

Add A Comment

Email Subscriptions
Author adds clarification
All new responses

Related Questions